Welcome to Windmill Harvest

Fresh food from family farms.

At Windmill Harvest, we offer fresh, handcrafted foods straight from our Amish farm and trusted neighboring farms here in Lancaster County. Whether it’s free-range eggs, pasture-raised meats, homemade baked goods, canned preserves, or seasonal produce—you can count on wholesome food made with care, simple ingredients, and traditional methods.

When you book a tour at Old Windmill Farm, you’ll have the chance to pre-order your favorite farm-fresh items. We’ll have your order packed and ready for pickup when you arrive—so you can take home a true taste of the farm.

Fresh Free-Range Eggs

Laid by organically fed, free-roaming hens—these eggs are rich in flavor, golden in yolk, and packed with nutrients your body will love.

Raw Milk from Grass-Fed Cows

Creamy, nutrient-dense, and full of natural enzymes—our raw milk is as close to nature as it gets, straight from healthy, pasture-raised cows. (Available in chocolate too!)

Hand-Churned Butter

Smooth, golden, and made in small batches—our butter brings rich flavor and wholesome tradition to every bite.

Meats & Cheeses

Crafted with care using traditional methods, our farm-fresh cheeses offer robust, natural flavor in every slice.

Our pasture-raised beef is tender, lean, and grown with integrity—no hormones, no shortcuts, just honest food from pasture to plate.

From the Farm to your Fridge

We love sharing the simple goodness of Old Windmill Farm with every family that visits.

Now, you can take a taste of the farm home with you!

After you book your visit, simply place your food order online, and we’ll have it packed and ready for you to pick up when your tour ends.

Order ahead and bring the farm home.

Why Fresh Free-Range Eggs Are a Nutritional Powerhouse

There’s nothing quite like cracking open a fresh egg from a free-range chicken. The golden yolk, firm white, and rich flavor tell you right away—this is no ordinary egg. But beyond taste, fresh free-range eggs offer real nutritional benefits.

Compared to conventional eggs, free-range eggs

often contain:

-More omega-3 fatty acids – great for heart and brain health

-Higher levels of vitamins A, D, and E

-More beta-carotene – that’s what gives the yolks their deep orange color

-Less cholesterol and saturated fat
Order ahead when you book your visit, and we’ll have your farm-fresh favorites ready to take home.

Weekly Inventory

Item↕	Availability↕	Price↕

Fresh food from family farms.

Grown with care. Shared with joy.

Sustainable Farming Practices

Farming that Feeds the Future

Support Local, Eat Local

Homegrown Goodness, Close to Home.

Fresh Food = Better Nutrition

Nutrient-Rich, Naturally

Frequently Asked Questions?

How do I place an order?

You can place a food order online. Just check the weekly inventory list to see what is available, and then click the "Order Now" button and complete the form. We'll pack up your order and have it ready for you to take home when you visit the farm.

Can I pick up food without booking a tour?

Yes! Just check the inventory available, and complete the order form online and be sure to arrive at the farm on your designed pickup date.

Is the milk pasteurized?

No, our milk is raw and unpasteurized, straight from grass-fed cows. It’s handled with care and chilled immediately after milking. Many of our customers seek raw milk for its taste and natural enzymes.

What kind of butter and cheese is available?

We offer fresh-churned butter made from raw cream and a rotating selection of handcrafted cheeses—availability changes weekly.

Is your beef grass-fed?

Our beef is pasture-raised and spend their days grazing on grass as they roam. At certain times of year, their food is supplemented with hay and/or grain. They are not treated with hormones or antibiotics.

What do your chickens eat?

Our chickens are free-range and organically fed. They roam during the day and return to the coop at night. Their varied diet leads to rich, flavorful eggs.

When will I get my food order?

Your order will be ready for you at the end of your farm visit. We’ll keep it chilled until then, so you can enjoy the tour without worry.

Where does the food come from?

All food is locally sourced from Lancaster area farms. While most of our sourcing farms are Amish family farms, all the farms we work with share our values of quality and sustainability.

What happens if something I ordered is out of stock?

Since our food is seasonal and produced in small batches, inventory can change quickly. We’ll let you know if substitutions are needed or offer you a refund.

How should I store raw milk or butter after pickup?

We recommend bringing a cooler with ice packs, especially during warm months. Raw milk and butter should be refrigerated as soon as possible.

What if I don't have a cooler?

If you don't have a cooler, we have some available for purchase. For small orders, we have disposable coolers available for $5. For larger orders, we have coolers available for $20.

How do I pay?

You can pay at pick up. We accept cash and credit.

"I’ve never tasted eggs this fresh in my life! Delicious! The yolks are so rich and golden. We won’t buy store-bought eggs again if we can help it."

– Karen M., West Chester, PA

"This butter is unreal—so creamy and flavorful, it melts like velvet. I used it in my baking and even my kids noticed the difference. It’s the kind of butter that makes toast feel fancy."

– Anita A., Aston, PA.

"We grilled the burgers we picked up from the farm, and they were hands-down the best we’ve ever had. You can really taste the difference—so flavorful! Love that it's so much healthier too!"

– Robert A., Upper Chichester, PA